The South African government is walking a fiscal tightrope, attempting to fund critical investments in education, health, and infrastructure amid high debt costs, rising global trade tensions, sluggish economic growth both locally and abroad, and mounting pressure for expanded social protection spending.
Earlier this year, academic experts from the University of Johannesburg, speaking on an SNG Grant Thornton facilitated podcast titled Trade and Taxes, laid out a roadmap to stimulate long-term growth. Professors emphasised that strategic investment was urgently needed in three core areas:
- Education: A focus on early childhood development, improved access and outcomes in higher education, and a decisive shift to align curricula with future demands, including introducing AI and technology training from an early age.
Improved investment on research and development to secure the future. - Health: Tangible improvements in health outcomes through increased hospital bed capacity and better nurse-to-patient and doctor-to-patient ratios.
- Infrastructure: A significant ramp-up in infrastructure investment to bolster the economy’s foundation.
The Finance Minister’s initial budget appeared to heed this advice (with the exception of improved investment planned on R&D), making provisions for childhood development and infrastructure. However, the plan to fund these investments, a proposed increase in Value-Added Tax (VAT), sparked immediate backlash. Following intense pressure from civil society, opposition parties, and a legal challenge, the government was forced to reverse the VAT hike.
Critically, the government did not scale back its planned expenditure. SARS committed to collecting additional revenue to curb the funding gap with additional savings expected in the future with the termination of the covid grant amongst other things.
SARS Misses Monthly Collection Targets, Threatening Funding Plan
In the interim, the governments funding strategy is partly predicated on the South African Revenue Service (SARS) generating more income without raising tax rates. SARS committed to collecting an additional R35 billion in 2025/26, on top of a R100 billion projection from the previous year, contingent on investment in its modernisation and debt collection capabilities.
However, newly released data from the National Treasury, which tracks collections monthly, reveals SARS has, on average over the six-month period, fallen short of their monthly targets.
Over the six months from April, revenue collection has missed its monthly goal by an average of R2.1 billion, with the target being exceeded only in the first month (April). This consistent underperformance raises doubts about achieving the full R35 billion required to balance the books.
According to the National Treasury, a breakdown of debt owed to SARS (both disputed and non-disputed) reveals the following:
Indirect Taxes (VAT, Customs, Excise)
